Moulton Laboratories
the art and science of sound
Principles of Multitrack Mixing: The Kick Drum/Bass Relationship
Dave Moulton, assisted by Peter Alhadeff and Alex Case
February 1993

Pop and rock means kick drum and bass. Mixing them well is essential.

1 2 3 4 5 6 >
The View from 2005: This is another early article I’m quite proud of. It takes a fresh look at the relationship between two of the three most important elements in the pop/rock mix. Naturally, it made its way into Total Recording.

The Kick Drum/Bass Relationship

The kick drum and the bass guitar are fundamental. I mean, like, fundamental! They represent the bedrock of musical expression, the foundation upon which the house of music is built. This has always been so. The low-frequency impulse and chordal foundation of music is common to virtually all music from all over the world and throughout history. And today’s high-powered, high-tech, industrial-strength rock and roll is no exception. The kick and bass are such an important part of our music that we must give them very special care, especially in recording. As musicians, producers, recording engineers and mix engineers, we absolutely have to fully understand the capabilities and musical significance of these two instruments, both independently and together. They are the primary tools we use to create music which communicates the emotions that live in the pulse, the groove, the chord changes, and the riffs of rock and roll music.

Keep in mind that rock music is very high-energy high-intensity music. It drives the body as well as the soul. And it relies heavily on the low frequencies provided by the kick drum and bass. Low frequency sound waves are generally the most powerful part of the music spectrum. With wave lengths longer than we are tall, low frequencies are felt as well as heard. We humans seem to get a kick out of this. The fact that human-sized bass drums existed before the year 3,000 BC. suggests this is not a new trend. Today we go to dance clubs and live concerts for that special low frequency full-body sensation. For a special thrill I personally like to go to the Fourth of July celebration at out local military-industrial complex, Fort Devens. It is a truly different experience (kind of like riding a rocket sled after driving around in a Yugo) to hear/feel the 5” howitzers let off a 21 round salute from, say, 300 yards away. YIKES!

Power in the Mix

The kick drum is the driving force, the rock and roll motor that makes our body move (in a contemporary echo of the primeval march of the nomad...). Its powerful impact cuts and slams through the rest of the music with a beat which drives our bodies into movement: anywhere from foot tapping to slam dancing. The pulse of music lies in the kick drum.

The bass guitar is the key communicator of harmony in almost any tune. Its deep fat sustained tone is easy for our ears to find in almost any kind of music and it provides a musical foundation on which the harmonies and melodies are built. Add rhythm and words and you've got a song.

In general, the kick drum produces a hard, loud musical attack with little or no pitch, while the bass guitar produces pitch with little attack. As a result, the kick drum is typically rhythmic and the bass usually harmonic. However, they certainly aren't limited to these functions. The bass guitar provides much of the rhythmic force and drive in many styles of music. Slap and pop techniques are a direct attempt to give bass more attack, and this is very effective. At the same time, drummers can provide melodies and harmonies through roto-toms and the various drums (real and synthesized) with definite or implied pitch. In fact, one can do almost anything with these instruments in special situations (move walls, fry eggs, achieve world peace and so on - that’s a joke), but in pop music these instruments really focus on their primary functions. With this in mind, let's consider the implications for mixdown.
NEXT> The Basics    
1 2 3 4 5 6 >

COMMENTS

Ohio     Jan 08, 2007 06:55 PM
Amazing article...

Thanks!
Joshua 
     Jan 27, 2011 11:44 AM
Hi, my compliments for this article, it really open mind.
i have a question for you; can you explain in dept the technic called "Pitched kick drum"?
for example:
what effect unit (from sequencer or 3rd part plugin) can make this?
how to choice what frequency target i have to set?

i hope it's no too late :D
thanks!
marco 
USA     May 02, 2011 06:23 PM
Just cruising around and found this site and set of articles - some good stuff here!!

marco - the thread is pretty old! the article is from 1993 - probably posted later AND the last comment was a thank you from 2007!!

but what you may want to consider is that your question has more than one answer depending on your process - If you are recording a real drummer then the entire kit should be tuned appropriately for the song AND room - it can be a challenge to discern the tonality of a kick, but that being said and with the knowledge that there is always a fundamental frequency - we push on-



Using samples, synthetics or combos (this might originate from software,hardware or realware) you may want to pay attention to the fundamental frequencies of your sound or layers of sound. Some software and hardware provides the ability to simply set.

A frequency analyzer may help you if the sound doesn't have strong harmonics near the fundamental.

Use a frequency to note chart or calculator- google will turn up these types of tools.

You might also use a vocode function to trigger a pitched sound with a kick envelope this could be mixed with or replace the trigger sound - a simple side chain setup can be used to trigger pitched sounds - sine waves have been quite popular for this.

If you are asking what the relative pitch should be - you will find no single "correct" answer. Key notes and the likely intervals as suspects could be tried.

Also don't forget about auto-tune - this can come in handy particularly if you want to change the sound/pitch according to song parts-

I'm pretty sure there are other ways to approach this-
audiodidactic 
india     Jun 26, 2011 11:50 AM
t's very Informative and helpful speacilly for the freshers, and i feel if it would have more questions added
seo 
     Sep 26, 2011 01:05 PM
Great Article, exactly what I was looking for.
Dane 

Post a Comment



rss2

rss atom