The Equal Loudness Contours
Dave Moulton
March 1997
What They are and What They Mean for your Mixing
The Equal Loudness Contours
Our auditory system is a wondrous and complex array of physical, neurological and psychological constructs, and hardly anything about it is simple. But one of the most difficult and confounding aspects of our auditory system, when we try to make recordings, is what we call the Equal Loudness Contours (also referred to, sometimes, as Fletcher-Munson Curves, also Phon Lines).
These contours are all the more bedeviling because their behavior is so smoothly masked by our consciousness. Mostly, we aren‘t really aware of their existence. But in the recording biz we ignore them at our peril. They have a profound effect on the frequency response of our recordings and their existence calls into question the very possibility of
ever having truly accurate recordings, especially when working with multitrack techniques.
What are the Equal Loudness Contours? Basically, they are curves that are the inverse of frequency response curves, so that they are literally curves of, well, equal loudness. When Fletcher and Munson did the first ones (in the ‘30s), they started with 1 kHz. at some known sound pressure level as a reference, and measured all other audible frequencies in comparison to 1 kHz., determining at what sound pressure level each frequency sounded “equally loud” as 1 kHz. The resulting curve is known as (duh!) an equal loudness curve, and it is, as I said above, the inverse of a frequency response curve. Whew! If the low frequency response of a system falls off, then it needs greater level at low frequency to provide “equal loudness.” Got it? Not a biggie.
What’s all the fuss about? Why are we discussing this?
COMMENTS
Singapore Feb 21, 2009 10:11 PM
Hi Dave,
I enjoyed reading your article even though I am not in the recording business. At least I know how complex it is and the science is really good to understand. I stumbled on your article as I was doing some general research on hearing as we are in the digital signal processing business. We use complex near real-time algorithms to process inputs from bluetooth headset devices, handsfree carkits, multiple microphone arrays, etc to reduce the noise, establish direction of sound arrival, cancel out echoes, etc. We have developed a handsfree carkit the size of a mobile phone which can output 95dB without the acoustic feedback even though the mic is on the same box. I learned a lot, although not fully understanding everything but believe that there's a lot more to understand to make a great product, as with the skills required in making great recordings.
Cheers and thanks!
Philip
Philip Tan
Groton, MA Feb 22, 2009 10:17 AM
Hi Philip!
Thanks for your commnts and kind thoughts about my article on Equal Loudness Contours. It sounds like your are hard at work on some really interesting (and probably quite important) stuff.
Good luck, and keep up the good work.
Best regards,
Dave Moulton
Ireland Sep 19, 2011 05:38 PM
Hello Dave, by any chance would you have the original 1950s 1/3 octave equal loudness curves in an Excel Spread Sheet format by any chance?